by Richard Watson
In Issue 2 Vol 3, Faye Yip gave us a
good insight into Sun Style Taijiquan. The Sun Style's history is quite
short compared to the other major styles. Sun Lutang (1861-1932) is
reported to have started his Taiji training when he was 56. Hence he
would have begun in 1917. He would of course have made rapid progress as
he was already a master of two internal styles "Xingyiquan" and "Bagua
Zhang". His daughter Sun Jian Jun lives in Beijing and still retains
close links with the Li family. The association began with Professor Li's
grandfather Master Li Yulin. In this issue I would like to examine and
present my own findings on the history and practice of Yang Style
Taijiquan.
Yang Luchan (1799-1872)
The story of Yang Style Taiji begins
with Yang Luchan. Yang came from the ancient town of Guangfu which is
located in Yongnian County, Handan Prefecture, Hebel Province. There are
many stories about the founder of what is considered the most widely
practised of the popular styles. Most accounts of his adventures appear
to be far from definitive although there must be a great deal of history
tucked away in the archives of the Yang family. When we look at the
early development we must remember it started out as a village art and
keeping records would have been far from the practitioners' minds. Two
other points to ponder are that the practice was surrounded by mystery,
there was a lack of technology for keeping records and many of the
practitioners would have been inarticulate.
Yang Zhenduo (1926- )
In his book on Yang Style, a forward by Gu Liuxin
states that because of poverty he had to leave his home at the age of
ten; he was of course referring to Yang Luchan. Yang Zhenduo is the
great grandson of the founder of the style, so it would appear that this
is reliable information. It is historically recorded that Yang journied
to Chenjiagou, Wenxian County in central China's Henan Province, to
earn a living. He worked as a servant for the Chen family and he also
made contact with the famous boxing master Chen Changxing (1771-1853), a
14th generation of the famous Chen family arts.
While in attendance to the Chen family he acquired
the skill of "Lao Jia" (Old Frame) Taijiquan as well as weapons,
sanshou and push hands training. Some accounts of his life suggest that
he travelled to the Chen village several times and others record the
duration of his stay as 30 years. Whatever account is true, all agree
that when he returned to Yongnian he was an accomplished and highly
skilled wushu master.
Yang took lodgings with the Wu family, the house was
shared by three brothers of the Wu clan and one of them, Wu Yu-xiang
(1812-1880), was later to create his own style of Taijiquan which would
subsequently lead to the development of the Hao and Sun family styles of
Taiji (more about these in later issues).
I understand at this time that Yang's skills were
known as "cotton boxing" or "soft boxing" and became known as the
skill of the soft overcoming the hard. Yang Luchan was later to receive
an appointment to teach his skills in the capital Peking (Beijing) and
was commanded to teach in the house of Prince Duan, a member of the
royal family. The royal family engaged many notable fighters as
bodyguards, instructors to the royal guard and also members of the royal
household. Yang's skill was of a nature that he could easily neutralise
antagonists without causing serious injury and as his fame spread he
became known as "Yang the Invincible". He was later to be appointed to
the "Qing Court" as Wushu (martial arts) officer.
Yang Banhou (1837-1892)
Yang Jianhou (1839-1917)
Yang Banhou and Yang Jianhou were the two Taijiquan
practitioner sons of Yang Luchan. It is recorded in the Taiji boxing
annals that Banhou was of a belligerent nature who liked to fight in
preference to teaching. He was not averse to accepting challenges on his
own behalf or for his father. It is also said that he was rather harsh
on students. It is said of the Banhou form that it contains elements of
the fast and explosive movements found in the style of the Chen village.
I once attended a Taiji conference in Yang Luchan's birthplace and many
of the attending experts performed demonstrations.
One such performance was claimed to be of Yang
Banhou's lineage, however its authenticity was questioned by large
groups of attending delegates. For posterity I videoed this form and it
certainly had the fast, explosive movements otherwise attributed to it.
Yang Luchan of course lived before video and photographic technology but
having learned from the Chen source it is reasonable to assume Yang
Luchan's form originally contained these elements.
The general assumptions of historians is that because
of his fierce nature and the disinterest in teaching there is a paucity
of information on the number one son. The probing into the history of
Taiji is an ongoing process and it is possible that some of the missing
material will be revealed in the fullness of time, on the other hand we
Taiji nuts love the speculation!
Yang Jianhou had three sons; his youngest son was to
become the most famous name in the development of 20th century Taijiquan
but should not detract from his own achievements. In Fu Sheng Yuan's
book "Authentic Yang Family Tai Chi", he says of Yang Jianhou: "he
possessed well developed Wu Shu skills and was particularly agile in his
forms. He had a profound knowledge of Taiji Dao (Sabre), Jian (Sword)
and Chiang (Spear). His eye-body coordination was superb and his
movements very fast. Jianhou is attributed with the revision of his
father's form to what became known as medium frame.
At this stage in the development of the Yang style it
is assumed the influence of the more dynamic moves from the Chen style
had disappeared.
Yang Chengfu (1883-1936)
Yang Shaohou (1862-1930)
We now have the third generation of the Yang family
with Yang Luchan's grandsons. Shaohou originally trained with his
father but later learned from his uncle Banhou, Shaohou
apparently had a bellicose nature similar to his
uncle. In his later life his form took on a different shade influenced
by his uncle. According to the previously mentioned Gu Liuxin his
movements alternated between fast and slow, hard and crisp Fajin, shouts
with an intimidating manner. The special characteristics of his art was
the use of the soft to overcome the hard, adhering, following, powerful
Fajin pushes, hitting, grasping, rending, splitting tendons, breaking
bones, striking vital points and interrupting the pulse. When Shaohou
was teaching his students he would immediately attack and strike them.
Although his students admired his skill they were rarely able to
complete the full course. Although he was as famous as his brother,
Chengfu's reputation flourished by comparison.
Yang Chengfu is seen by most commentators as the 20th
century innovator who revised his father's medium frame and
standardished the large frame of Yang Style Taijiquan, furthermore it
clearly distinguished his form from that of his uncle Banhou's small
frame style. Chengfu's style clearly differs from its precursor from
Chenjiagou, gone are the jumping kicks, the stamping, the alternating
slow with fast movements. The movements of Yang style are considered by
comparison to be straight forward and simplified, they display slow
circular movements that have been compared to drawing silk. Most Taiji
players know of Yang Chengfu's ten important pointers to correct
practise, these valuable training guides are
elucidated in Fu Sheng Yuan's book "Authentic Yang
Family Tai Chi." The three generations of the Yang family were well
established in north China. In his later years Chengfu took his skills
to the south, visiting Nanjing, Shanghai, Hangzhou, Guangzhou and
Hangkou. He was continuing what his grandfather had initiated, the
spread of Taijiquan throughout China.
The 4th Generation,
Yang Sau Chung (1909-1985)
Yang Zhenji ( ). Yang Zhendou (1926- )
Yang Zhenji is chairman of the Taiyuan Wushu
Association, Shanxi Province. We have heard very little of him in the
West until quite recently. He does teach Taiji in China and I have seen
reports of students travelling to China to train with him and I
understand he also travels abroad to organise Taiji conferences although
he appears to keep a low profile. Yang Zhendou should be considered the
standard bearer of Yang style in mainland China as a 4th generation of
the illustrious family, however he was only nine years old when his
father died and the considered opinion of most commentators is that he
would have been too young to receive direct tuition.
In Yang Zhendou's own book, mentioned earlier,
Zhendou states that he learned from his father, Yang Chengfu and elder
brothers, Yang Zhenming (also known as Yang Sau Chung) and Yang Zhenji.
He says he learned from them in his youth, however as he was only nine
years old when his father died we can assume that his father's direct
influence would have been minimal. Howard Choy has told me that in a
conversation with Fu Zhongwen (more about him later, Fu said that he was
the significant teacher in Zhendou's training. In recent years and
mostly in the last decade Yang Zhendou, accompanied by his grandson Yang
Jun, has travelled all over the world spreading the word of his Yang
style Taijiquan. His travels have included visits to Britain.
Yang Sau Chung, the eldest son of Chengfu began to
train at the age of eight and in his own book "Practical Use of
Taijiquan," he says he became accomplished in Taiji, Sabre, Spear,
Sword and became his father's assistant at the age of 14 and taught
under his father's guidance. There are many records of Sau Chung
accompanying his father on his travels throughout China. When his father
died in 1936 he would have spent nineteen years under his direct
influence, while Yang Chengful had many important disciples and
students, as the eldest son it would be reasonable to assume that he was
the rightful inheritor of his father's title. At the time of Sau
Chung's death in 1985, Taiji had not gained its 21st century popularity
and although he had many students he appears to have led a reclusive
life.
I am not aware of any extensive writings and unlike
many of today's experts he was not a Taiji nomad. He left China in 1949
at the time of Mao's Republic and up to the time of his death he
probably would not have been welcomed back.
Although he remained in Hong Kong until his death, he
has through his students, had considerable influence in the West. One
must remember that during the cultural revolution, Taiji teachers were
persecuted as intellectuals and were compelled to keep a low profile.
Leaving aside his disciples, he states in his book: "I have been very
demanding and strict with all my students, particularly with my dauthers
Amy, Tai-Yee, Mary, Ma-Lee, Agnes, Yee-Li," so there are a lot of the
5th generation of the Yang family out there. In addition, Yang Sau Chung
adopted three disciples. In order of their seniority they are as
follows: Ip Tai-Tak, Chu Gin-Soon, Chu King-Hung.
Ip Tai-Tak lives in Hong Kong but he has travelled to
Britain at the invitation of John Ding who has been adopted by Ip as his
first disciple. John and I were class-mates and colleagues in the
1970-80s with the ITCCA under the tuteleage of Master Chu King-Hung. Chu
Gin-Soon teaches in Boston USA and he has taught in Britain and Europe.
I was fortunate to be introduced to Yang Sau Chung by
Master Chu King Hung. Of my Taiji associates and friends Ermano Cossi of
Milan and Howard Choy of Sidney have been one-to-one students of Yang
Sau-Chung. There are of course many important students across the five
generations, some are well known and some not so well known. Among the
famous we have Fu Zhong-Wen, Chen Wei-Ming, Dong, Ying-Jie. Fu
Zhong-Wen's son Fu Sheng-Yuan names in his book "Authentic Yang Family
Tai Chi", fourteen disciples. Being the son of his famous father he can
speak with some authority, however he includes himself among the
fourteen while he gives his own birth date as 1931. He would have been
five years old at the time of Yang Cheng-Fu's death so it seems
unlikely that this discipleship would be correct, but it is indicative
of the importance paid to the lineage connections.
Fu Zhong-Wen (1903-1994)
Fu Sheng-Yuan (1933)
Fu Zhong-Wen was the nephew of Yang Cheng-Fu and was
already training with his uncle at the age of ten, making this Yang's
longest serving disciple/student as far as I can ascertain. Fu dedicated
his whole life to self-cultivation through the practise of Yang style
Taiji and he travelled extensively with his teacher assisting him in
teaching and according to his son, accepting Fu's push hands
challenges. In his book "Authentic Yang Style",
Fu Sheng-Yuan states that on the death of Yang
Cheng-Fu the leadership of the Yang family passed to Fu Zhong-Wen. This
would appear unlikely when the eldest son, Yang Sau-Chung was alive and
well and living in China. Earlier I observed that Sau-Chung left China
in 1949 and from this period Master Fu would have been the dominant
dignitary of the Yang family. After Yang's death Fu established the
Yongnian TCC Society of Shanghai to continue to propagate the Yang
family arts. Fu Shen-Yuan and his son Qing-Quan are also engaged in the
process and more information on this important connection can be gleaned
from Fu Sheng-Yuan's book.
After Yang's death his first adopted disciple Chen
Wei-Ming, wrote to Fu Zhong Wen acknowledging the excellence and
accuracy with which he reflected their masters art. In 1963 Fu Zhong-Wen
published his book "Yang Style Taijiquan." In 1999 this unique book
was translated by Louis Swaim and published in English and called "Mastering Yang Style Taijiquan."
In his preface, Master Fu tells us "to the best of
my ability I have written in accordance with the requirements for each
posture as advanced by my former teacher in his verbal instructions to
me; I've neither added nor taken away. I have seen adverse criticism of
this book, but for the perfectionist it deals in the minute detail for
understanding Jin in accordance with application." At any rate any
information recorded by teachers of this
calibre is worth a read. Fu was an important figure
in the traditional Taiji renaissance that took place after the end of
the cultural revolution at the passing away of Mao Tse Tung, he was a
vital link with Taijiquan's early and mid-20th century history.
Dong Yingjie, Dong Huling, Dong Jiying,
Dong Zenchen, Alex Dong.
The Dong family are a most important and influential
connection with the Yang style Taijiquan. Dong Yingjie (1888-1961) is
reported to have studied with Yang Cheng-Fu for 20 years and the
unbroken tradition has continued through to the present day with his
great grandson Alex Dong. Dong Yingjie (sometimes Tung Ying-Chiet), was
a top exponent among the leading disciples of Yang and he travelled
extensively and assisted his teacher on teaching and demonstration
tours. Prior to learning from Yang he studied the Wu style of Taiji from
Li Xiang-Yuan (Wu style of Wu Yu-Xiang not Wu Jian-Quan). Dong taught in
his own right, spreading his art throughout southeast Asia, travelling
to Hong Kong, Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore. His son
Huling continued this work, eventually migrating to Hawaii. Huling's
eldest son Jiying, moved to the mainland USA to extend their influence
to Los Angeles and San Francisco.
The young son, Dong Zenchen, left their ancestral
home in Hebei Province to join his family in Hawaii around 1983. Zenchen
brought the Dong family art to Europe, including Britain, during the
late 1980s and early 90s and his son Alex Dong travels to Britain on an
annual basis. The current host is Louise Bouck-Standen and the
organisation is the Dong Family International Tai Chi Chuan Association.
I was fortunate to avail myself of tuition from
Master Dong Zenchen during his early visits to Britain, completing his
long form and the unique Dong Family fast form and to push hands with
Master Dong and his son Alex. There are Yang stylists that perform a
fast form comprised of a section from the long form simply speeded up.
This is not the case with the Dong fast form which
may also benefit from the association with the Wu style. One thing that
is noteworthy of the Dong family is the unbroken tradition. There are
published photographs of three generations and from my own experience
with Zenchen and Alex Dong one can see they faithfully follow the
characteristics of the great grandfather Master Dong Yingjie.
One interesting anecdote couched from a 1990 edition
of the magazine "Fighers" is: "Dong Jiying, established quite
unwittingly to his own repution way back in China, where the much
publicised Cheng Man-Ching, trying to build his own
repution had gone to match his pushing hands skills with Dong Huling.
Accepting the challenge, the Dongs decided instead to give the young
Jiying an opportunity to gain some experience at the age of 17. Jijing
met the older challenger and was not only able to neutralise and uproot
his opponent but also send him flying all over the place."
Chen Wei Ming
In Fu Sheng-Yuan's book mentioned earlier he states
that Chen Wei-Ming was the first disciple of Yang Cheng-Fu. I am not
aware of the lineage or the history of Chen's students, however Dan
Docherty has mentioned that his senior student Liang Ching-Yu, was a
Hong Kong resident. Chen Wei-Ming's valuable contribution to Taijiquan's
body of students is in his book "Tai Chi Chuan Ta Wen"
(questions and answers on Tai Chi Chuan). The book was translated in
1985 by Benjamin Pang Jeng Lo, the original work was published in
Shanghai in 1929.
Chen came to Shanghai in 1925, founded his own school
and assumed the role of a Taiji teacher. He had previously spent eight
years studying with Yang Cheng-Fu. The book deals with the questions
Chen put to Yang and Yang's answers on a whole range of Taiji subjects
and the following is dealt with in some detail. Commentary on History
and Correction of the Legend.
Tai Chi Form, Tai Chi Push Hands, Tai Chi Fighting
Technique (San Shou) Chin (Internal Force) of Tai Chi, The Relationship
of Tai Chi to Daoyin and Meditation Tai Chi: Physique and Achievement,
Five Character Secret of Li I-Yu.
Cheng Man-Ching (1900-1976)
Perhaps the most well known, the most written about
with himself a prolific writer and known as a man of the five
excellences: Painting, Poetry, Calligraphy, Medicine and Taijiquan.
Cheng Man-Ching's name and fame is widespread throughout the western
world, Taiwan, Malasia and Singapore. To some extent lionised by the
famous United States' writer and martial artist Robert Smith who is
co-author with Cheng for the book "Tai Chi, the Supreme Ultimate
Exercise for Health, Sport and Exercise."
Cheng's Taiji Training
(Cheng Tzu's Thirteeen Treaties on Tai Chi Chuan)
by Cheng Man-Ching, 1947
In this book, translated by Benjamin Pang Jeng Lo in
1985, Madame Cheng's introduction informs us that her late husband took
up Tai Chi because of his poor physical condition being at the time
Professor of Literature at Shanghai University and Head of the Chinese
Traditional Painting Department of the Fine Arts Academy of Shanghai and
because of his heavy work commitments he experienced lung problems.
Fortunately he was introduced to the great Tai Chi Master Yang Cheng-Fu.
She goes on to say that he studied every day with Yang for six years.
Because of the profound effect in improving his health, Cheng set out on
a course of spreading the art to the widest possible audience.
On one of my early trips to Beijing, arranged and
accompanied by the late Jifu Huang, to the Peoples' University, I was
compromised into demonstration of Cheng's Routine of 37 Forms. I had
trained some Cheng style with the Penang Tai Chi Chuan Association
including a brief trip to visit and study with Master Khoo Teng-Hock
during the years 1982-1986. The reason for the demonstration was that
the Taiji authorities at the university were not familiar with the style
of Cheng Man-Ching. The explanation, of course, for their lack of
awareness is that Cheng left the mainland to be domiciled in Taiwan at
the termination of the Peoples' Revolution. He was a supporter of the
nationalist cause and its leader Chiang Kai-Shek.
Although a few westerners had brought some Taiji to
the west, Cheng Man Ching should be regarded as the first Taiji pilgrim.
Professor Li De-Yin remarked that Cheng laid the foundation
for all the Taiji teachers that have followed him to the west.
Although the source of Cheng's Taiji is the Yang
Style of Yang Cheng-Fu there is a strong support that it displays its
own unique characteristics and regardless of its derivation maybe it
should be referred to as Cheng's Taijiquan. I prefer the postures when
he was younger as they appear in the aforementioned book "Cheng
Tzu's Thirteen Treaties on Tai Chi Chuan", to those illustrated in
the co-authorship book with Robert Smith.
There are a number of old movies around showing Cheng
in action which should give some inspiration to his followers although
this very often is not the case. One can understand the early
fascination westerners held over Cheng when you see on the old movies
his Fajin performance.
However it is a quarter of a century since he died
and there are many high level teachers coming from the east and there
are many western exponents who can expertly show these skills,
especially when they are executed on their own students.
I cannot, being of cynical nature, comment on Cheng
without referring to Douglas Wile's compilation entitled: "Cheng
Man-Ching's Advanaced Tai Chi Form Instructions."
In this book there's a double preface and without
recording the full content, here is the gist. Teng Ko-Yu's preface
reads: "While visiting Chungking we accepted an invitation to the
British Embassy to demonstrate Taiji and a challenge was issued to the
attendant British soldiers, 'all of you gentlemen are large and
powerful, would you like to step forward and test him?' (Cheng). The
best fighter stepped forward and asked about the rules. 'Try anything
you like' was the answer. The soldier raised his left arm and waved his
right fist. Man Ching threw him down several paces away. Again raising
his right arm and waving his left fist he was thrown in the same manner.
Finally aiming both fists at Man Ching's head, Cheng stuck him and both
his feet left the ground and he fell backwards all the way to the
contest area. Cheng swiftly caught him up and
lifted him by the arm, preventing him from falling on his back. The
other soldiers stood by and did not dare to try him."
The second preface by Chen Wei-Ming: "One day he
had a contest with fifteen American soldiers stationed in China. After
defeating six of them, the rest were too frightened to continue. This
became a celebrated incident at the time." Come off it Mr Wile, how
much damage did the man do to the Japanese army during the Sino/Japanese
war?
There have been many famous followers of the Cheng
Man-Ching system and there are many unsung followers of all Taijiquan
styles and when Fu Shen-Yuan visited my home he spotted Li Yulin's
picture on my wall. He put both thumbs up to acknowledge his Taiji
skills but we can find very little published documentation on him. Cheng
Man-Ching was the first teacher to shorten the
original Yang long form and this was for very practical reasons. When
later the Wushu authorities developed the short Yang form known as the
Twenty Four Simplified Taijiquan they were heavily criticised for doing
so. However the last ten years or so all the traditional and recognised
styles have followed suit, perhaps implying that Cheng's shortened form
was quite visionary.
Characteristics of
Yang Family Taijiquan
Yang style has developed from its origin of the
Chen's 'Laojia', significant changes have taken place in the twentieth
century as the art moved its emphasis from martial to health
preservation and self cultivation. The Yang style left out the
alternating fast and slow. The Chen obvious use of the silk reeling
movements with distinct transitions to 'Fajin' methods. This so called
simplifying of Taijiquan was to make Yang style immensely popular on the
world stage. I would like to make the observation that its accessibility
is a different ball game to its mastery.
The question of mastery propounds the same
considerations for all styles.
The Yang style adopts a slow and even pace also
emphasising the technique of "sinking the qi to dantian." The
newsletter is currently recording Yang Cheng-Fu's "Ten Important
Points for Practice", and these can be valuable insights for Taiji
training at the many levels of development. Yang Cheng-Fu is accredited
with the saying: "Taijiquan is the art of softness containing
hardness, of a needle concealed in cotton wool."
His recorded instructions included that one must be
natural, relaxed. The postures must be centred and upright, rounded and
full, movements should be light and lively (containing heaviness), calm
and tranquil. Another essential of Yang family Taiji is
the development of 'Jin' and the training and
understanding of the applications of 'Fajin.'
These are difficult concepts to understand and long
training with competent instruction is important, hence the instruction
to perservere with diligence and sincerity. Taijiquan takes its
philosophical inspiration from the book of changes (l'Ching), the
principle of Wu Chi (The Great Nothingness), Taiji (The Grand Ultimate)
and the understanding of the cyles of Yin and Yang. Yang style, like all
the major styles make reference to the
collection of works referred to as the Taiji
classics. These insights by authors known and unknown have served as
anecdotal philosophical and psychological sustenance.
This article is the briefest introduction to some of
the characteristics of Yang Style, and there are many books dealing with
the subject in comprehensive fashion as indeed there are for the whole
subject matter of Taijiquan.
Richard Watson
Back to contents
|